Last Modified: 2005-06-02
Done | First version of the HIP basic mobility and multi-homing mechanism specification. | |
Done | First version of the HIP DNS resource record(s) specification. | |
Done | First version of the HIP basic rendezvous mechanism specification. | |
Dec 04 | WGLC on the HIP architecture specification | |
Jan 05 | Submit the HIP architecture specification to the IESG | |
Mar 05 | WG LC on the base protocol specification | |
Mar 05 | WG LC on the base protocol specification | |
Apr 05 | Complete the base protocol specification and submit it to the IESG for Experimental | |
Done | WG LC on the HIP basic mobility and multi-homing specification. | |
Apr 05 | WG LC on the basic HIP rendezvous mechanism specification. | |
May 05 | Submit the HIP DNS resource record(s) specification to the IESG for Experimental. | |
May 05 | Submit the HIP basic mobility and multihoming specification to the IESG for Experimental. | |
May 05 | Submit the basic HIP rendezvous mechanism specification to the IESG for Experimental. | |
May 05 | Recharter or close the WG. |
Minutes HIP WG at IETF 63
Minutes edited by Gonzalo Camarillo Based on notes by Andrew McGregor Meeting chaired by Gonzalo Camarillo and David Ward MONDAY, August 1, 2005, 1400-1600 Topic: Agenda Bash Discussions led by: Chairs There were no comments on the agenda Topic: Status Discussions led by: Chairs Architecture draft: Tom Henderson is incorporating the comments received from the IESG because both Pekka and Bob did not have time to do this. Tom will have a new revision addressing all the comments received right after this IETF meeting (i.e., in one week). Base HIP spec and ESP draft: the WGLC is over. Petri Jokela (the editor of both drafts) will have a new revision ready to be sent to the IESG in a couple of weeks. Rest of our WG items: the idea is to request their publication before the end of the year. Topic: Base HIP spec Discussion led by: Petri Jokela Relevant document: draft-ietf-hip-base-03.txt In principle, the draft will keep informative and normative references. Petri will analyze the normative references in order to see whether the draft depends on other drafts that will not be ready for publication soon. A draft is needed in order to trigger discussions within the IPv6 community on how to encode the hashing algorithm in a HIT. Pekka offered his help with the draft, but nobody volunteered to actually write it. The chairs will look for a volunteer off-line or, if nobody wants to do the job, they will write it themselves. There was consensus in the room to remove type 2 HITs. Petri will send a note to the list and to Bob to confirm that it is OK to remove them. Topic: ESP draft Discussion led by: Petri Jokela Relevant document: draft-ietf-hip-esp-00.txt Petri will add some clarifications about the ESP_INFO parameter. Topic: Mobility and Multihoming Discussion led by: Pekka Nikander Relevant document: draft-ietf-hip-mm-02.txt The draft now is aligned with the base HIP spec and the ESP draft. Address checks for new addresses is now mandatory. Credit-based authorization used for new addresses to prevent amplification attacks. The draft now follows the guidelines of RFC 4101 (Writing Protocol Models). Policies are now outside the scope of the draft. When updating address sets, there was consensus in the room to use full sets instead of deltas, although deltas could be useful in cases involving large numbers of addresses. Pekka will check in the list whether or not is OK to only use full sets. The WGLC on this draft is expected to take place around November. Topic: HIP DNS Extensions Discussion led by: Julien Laganier Relevant document: draft-ietf-hip-dns-02.txt The draft should point out the benefits of initially performing a single DNS query, instead of performing several in parallel (i.e., if the initial query fails the client can avoid performing the rest of them). However, the draft should not mandate this behavior, although it could recommend it. Julien will follow the discussion on the removal of type 2 HITs. Once that discussion is resolved, the draft will be ready for WGLC. Topic: HIP Registration Extensions Discussion led by: Julien Laganier Relevant document: draft-koponen-hip-registration-01 Initially these extensions were part of the rendezvous draft. The chairs will talk to the AD in order to add this to our charter. Topic: HIP Rendezvous Servers Extensions Discussion led by: Julien Laganier Relevant document: draft-ietf-hip-rvs-03.txt Julien will check with Hannes about the implementation status and report to the list. This draft will be ready for WGLC fairly soon. |