Last Modified: 2005-02-18
Done | Submit revised variables draft. | |
Done | Submit revised vacation draft. | |
Done | WG last call for variables draft. | |
Done | Initial submission of RFC 3028bis. | |
Dec 04 | WG last call for vacation draft. | |
Jan 05 | WG last call for RFC 3028bis. | |
Jan 05 | Initial submission of revised relational draft. | |
Done | Initial submission of revised subaddress draft. | |
Jan 05 | Submit variables draft to IESG. | |
Jan 05 | Submit vacation draft to IESG. | |
Done | Initial submission of revised spamtest/virustest draft. | |
Done | Submit revised editheader draft. | |
Done | Submit revised imapflags draft. | |
Feb 05 | Submit RFC 3028bis to IESG. | |
Feb 05 | WG last call of revised relational draft. | |
Feb 05 | WG last call of revised subaddress draft. | |
Feb 05 | WG last call of revised spamtest/virustest draft. | |
Done | Submit revised body test draft. | |
Feb 05 | Submit revised reject before delivery draft. | |
Feb 05 | WG last call for editheader draft. | |
Feb 05 | Submit revised relational draft to IESG. | |
Feb 05 | Submit revised subaddress draft to IESG. | |
Feb 05 | Submit revised spamtest/virustest draft to IESG. | |
Feb 05 | WG last call for imapflags draft. | |
Mar 05 | Submit revised notification action draft. | |
Mar 05 | WG last call for body test draft. | |
Mar 05 | WG last call for reject before delivery draft. | |
Mar 05 | Submit editheader draft to IESG. | |
Mar 05 | Submit imapflags draft to IESG. | |
Apr 05 | Submit revised MIME part tests draft. | |
Apr 05 | WG last call for notification action draft. | |
Apr 05 | Submit body test draft to IESG. | |
Apr 05 | Submit revised reject before delivery draft to IESG. | |
May 05 | Submit notification action draft to IESG. | |
May 05 | WG last call for MIME part tests draft. | |
May 05 | Create list of core sieve features; collect implementation information for interoperability report. | |
Jun 05 | Submit MIME part tests draft to IESG. |
Minutes of SIEVE BOF at IETF 62, 07-Mar-2005
(Raw log at <http://www.xmpp.org/ietf-logs/sieve@ietf.xmpp.org/2005-03-07.txt>) - MEETING OPENED Apologies from Cyrus, Alexey, though they are present on Jabber/audio. Agenda bashing - no changes to agenda. WG Status: WG was approved by IESG in November. TOPIC: Base spec discussion - References changed/split - E-mail -> email - Errate fixed - Reject cancels implicit keep - Reference comparator draft instead of ACAP - Grammar update to UTF-8 in progress - Other typos, errors, boilerplate - Issue: Sync with collation draft: SIEVE/ACAP use different case-insensitive comparator name - Suggestion: require support for new name and must support the old one - Discussion on recyling: consensus that we have to recycle for this change and others. Start current draft as proposed and do implementation report immediately so it can go to draft status in 6 months. - Issue: allow bare CR & LF in scripts? Currently not legal but grammar allows it. - No consensus at the meeting on this. - Issue: backslash escaping, \ quotes immediately following character - no special \0, \xNN etc. One implementation treats \0 as NULL character. Any change will not be backwards compatible. - Possible options for base spec: specifiy that \x is special; \" \\ are defined but other \xx will be defined by extensions; leave it the way it is, use variables to define variable namespace for unicode chars. - Consensus was to try to maintain backwards compatability with first or second option. Phil will send proposed text to the mailing list. - Issue: update to 2821 & 2822 references. Problem is those are still at proposed. - 2821 & 2822 authors report that not a lot of work is needed to go to draft - just time. - People can volunteer to help 2821/2822 authors with that. TOPIC: IMAP Flags - Minor changes only - Issue: use of global variable for flag state and how does that work with multiple keeps? Consensus was to go ahead with such a change and then review in new spec. TOPIC: Refuse - Nothing done yet. - Discussion of difference between reject and refuse. - Need to see new spec to go further with this. Alexey is working on it. TOPIC: Relational - New draft available. - Only minor changes done. - Ready for last call? No objections. TOPIC: Subaddress - New draft available. - Issue: how to handle multiple separator characters? Use left-most or do whatever local MTA does? Consensus was to use MTA rules since MTA determines what character is used as well. TOPIC: Spamtest - New draft available. - Added :percent parameter. - Issue: what numeric range to use? Current spec uses -1..100 but SIEVE comparator does not test negative numbers. - Consensus on proposed solution: split out untested and tested via a separate parameter. - Consensus was to not add additional scales to the test. TOPIC: Variables - Last call complete. - Last call comments require minor changes. - Issue: how to handle ${0}? Two options: returns match string or returns number of matches? - Consensus was for returning match string as that is the only way to do glob style matching. TOPIC: Vacation - Ned takes over as editor. - Will add :from parameter. - Will add [AUTO] as prefix for subject. - Issue: how to deal with security implications of allowing user to set from address? Consensus was to add text to security considerations section indicating that this may be of concern. TOPIC: Body - New draft available. - Ready for last call? No objections. TOPIC: Edit header - New draft available. - Ready for last call? No objections. TOPIC: Notify - Barry will take over as editor. - Issue: is it too complex? - Issue: how to deal with SMS? - Use of associative arrays or URIs as proposed on the list? - Barry will produce new draft. TOPIC: Regex - Ned has i18n regex discussion document that he will post to the list. TOPIC: MIME part tests - Several proposals: modifiers to existing tests; new tests; looping construct. - Discussion of whether loops might make sieve too complex. No real consensus on this, but must people did not want too much complexity. - Cyrus/Tony will come up with new draft. TOPIC: Milestones - A number completed - good. - A number overdue - bad! - ADs prefer dates that are meant rather than overly agreesive dates that are missed. - Cyrus/Alexey will work on updated (realistic) new milestones. No other issues. - MEETING CLOSED |
None received.