Last Modified: 2004-10-20
Minutes of SIEVE BOF at IETF 61, 11-Nov-2004
(Raw log at <http://www.xmpp.org/ietf-logs/sieve@ietf.xmpp.org/2004-11-11.txt>) - MEETING OPENED Agenda bashing - no changes to agenda. Apologies from Alexey, stuck in UK. History lesson of SIEVE from Cyrus. Current proposed WG status: IESG are talking about WG formation at next telechat Thursday, unless something drastic happens, there should be a WG. TOPIC: Base spec revision - List of issues from Tim presented. - Most issues are relatively minor. - Major issue: variables draft needs a side-effect on test, but base draft says MUST NOT. Needs to be fixed. - No other issues brought up. TOPIC: Relation revision - Issue: ge, gt, etc not specified. - No other issues brought up. TOPIC: Subaddress revision - No issues brought up. - No need to rev right now. TOPIC: Spamtest/Virustest - Request for :percent parameter. - Consensus to add this in a backwards compatible manner with new 'require' capability. - Cyrus will rev spec. TOPIC: Variables -05 recently posted to mailing list. - Still need discussion on how it interacts with other actions. - Discussed interaction with base spec and requirement to loosen MUST NOT in base. - Consensus was to get revised base spec draft first then do WGLC on variables. - Question about whether setdate was needed. Consensus was that it can wait. TOPIC: Vacation - Request for :from argument to allow setting MAIL FROM or From: header in vacation message. - Needed to help with case of multiple addresses tied to a single mailbox. - Consensus was to add :from argument to vacation with new 'require' capability for backwards compatibility. - Tim should revise spec and then we WGLC it. TOPIC: Body test - Issue on use of :binary - can it be removed. - Consensus to remove :binary. - Issue with interaction with variables and :regex and :matches scans only in body. - Jutta will make changes and submit ready for WGLC. TOPIC: Edit Header - Issue on use of deleteheader :index/:last arguments - are they needed? - Jutta will make this change and submit revised spec for discussion. TOPIC: regexp draft - Issue of interaction with variables. - Ken will properly reference variables. - Issue of i18n unicode regex's. - No consensus on appropriate way forward on this after much debate. - Committee of Ken, Ned & John K to research this and report back. TOPIC: MIME parts test - Consensus that this is a worthwhile test to have. - Authors of two current proposals will get together and produce a unified spec. TOPIC: Refuse test - Debate about whether two actions or one should be used for this. - Consensus was to remove 'reject' from base spec and have a new draft for modified 'reject' command. - No consensus on details of unified action - authors will submit new draft for discussion. TOPIC: IMAP flags - Should spec reference variables or do its own thing (as it does now). - General agreement that we need to pick one way to do this and get on with it! - Consensus in room was go away and figure this out on the mailing list. TOPIC: Notify - Ned will take over authorship of draft. Other issues: - Q: interest in resurrecting script interaction draft? - There seem to be some differences in how existing implementations exactly do this, and reluctance to make changes to conform to the draft. - MEETING CLOSED |
None received.